First Basemen
- Will Clark, Giants
- John Kruk, Phillies*
- Eddie Murray, Dodgers
Second Basemen
- Delino DeShields, Expos*
- Juan Samuel, Dodgers
- Ryne Sandberg, Cubs
Third Basemen
- Howard Johnson, Mets
- Terry Pendleton, Braves
- Chris Sabo, Reds
Shortstops
- Tony Fernandez, Padres
- Barry Larkin, Reds
- Ozzie Smith, Cardinals
Outfielders
- George Bell, Cubs
- Bobby Bonilla, Pirates
- Brett Butler, Dodgers*
- Ivan Calderon, Expos
- Andre Dawson, Cubs
- Tony Gwynn, Padres
- Felix Jose, Cardinals*
- Paul O'Neill, Reds*
- Darryl Strawberry, Dodgers
Catchers
- Craig Biggio, Astros
- Benito Santiago, Padres
- Mike Scioscia, Dodgers
Pitchers
- Tom Browning, Reds
- Rob Dibble, Reds
- John Franco, Mets (added to the team in 2012)
- Tom Glavine, Braves*
- Pete Harnisch, Astros*
- Dennis Martinez, Expos
- Ramon Martinez, Dodgers
- Mike Morgan, Dodgers*
- John Smiley, Pirates*
- Lee Smith, Cardinals
- Frank Viola, Mets
- Mitch Williams, Phillies (added to the team in 2012)
Manager:
First Basemen
- Cecil Fielder, Tigers
- Mark McGwire, Athletics
- Rafael Palmeiro, Rangers
Second Basemen
- Roberto Alomar, Blue Jays
- Julio Franco, Rangers
- Steve Sax, Yankees
Third Basemen
- Wade Boggs, Red Sox
- Paul Molitor, Brewers
- Robin Ventura, White Sox*
Shortstops
- Felix Fermin, Indians*
- Ozzie Guillen, White Sox
- Cal Ripken, Orioles
Outfielders
- Harold Baines, Athletics
- Joe Carter, Blue Jays
- Ken Griffey, Jr., Mariners
- Dave Henderson, Athletics
- Rickey Henderson, Athletics
- Kirby Puckett, Twins
- Tim Raines, White Sox
- Ruben Sierra, Rangers
- Danny Tartabull, Royals*
Catchers
- Carlton Fisk, White Sox
- Brian Harper, Twins*
- Mickey Tettleton, Tigers
Pitchers
- Jim Abbott, Angels* (added to the team in 2012)
- Rick Aguilera, Twins*
- Roger Clemens, Red Sox
- Dennis Eckersley, Athletics
- Scott Erickson, Twins* (added to the team in 2012)
- Bryan Harvey, Angels*
- Jimmy Key, Blue Jays*
- Mark Langston, Angels
- Jack McDowell, White Sox*
- Jack Morris, Twins
- Jeff Reardon, Red Sox
- Scott Sanderson, Yankees*
Manager:
