First Basemen
- Jack Clark, Cardinals
- Andres Galarraga, Expos
- Keith Hernandez, Mets
Second Basemen
- Tom Herr, Cardinals
- Juan Samuel, Phillies
- Ryne Sandberg, Cubs
Third Basemen
- Terry Pendleton, Cardinals
- Mike Schmidt, Phillies
- Tim Wallach, Expos
Shortstops
- Hubie Brooks, Expos
- Shawon Dunston, Cubs
- Ozzie Smith, Cardinals
Outfielders
- Eric Davis, Reds
- Andre Dawson, Cubs
- Pedro Guerrero, Dodgers
- Tony Gwynn, Padres
- Jeffrey Leonard, Giants
- Willie McGee, Cardinals
- Dale Murphy, Braves
- Tim Raines, Expos
- Darryl Strawberry, Mets
Catchers
- Gary Carter, Mets
- Bo Diaz, Reds
- Ozzie Virgil, Braves
Pitchers
- Steve Bedrosian, Phillies
- Mike Dunne, Pirates
- Sid Fernandez, Mets
- John Franco, Reds
- Dwight Gooden, Mets
- Orel Hershiser, Dodgers
- Mike Scott, Astros
- Lee Smith, Cubs
- Rick Sutcliffe, Cubs
- Fernando Valenzuela, Dodgers
- Todd Worrell, Cardinals (added to the team in 2012)
Manager:
First Basemen
- Don Mattingly, Yankees
- Larry Parrish, Rangers
- Pat Tabler, Indians
Second Basemen
- Willie Randolph, Yankees
- Harold Reynolds, Mariners
- Lou Whitaker, Tigers
Third Basemen
- Wade Boggs, Red Sox
- Mark McGwire, Athletics
- Kevin Seitzer, Royals
Shortstops
- Tony Fernandez, Blue Jays
- Cal Ripken, Orioles
- Alan Trammell, Tigers
Outfielders
- Harold Baines, White Sox
- Jesse Barfield, Blue Jays
- George Bell, Blue Jays
- Jose Canseco, Athletics
- Joe Carter, Indians
- Dwight Evans, Red Sox
- Rickey Henderson, Yankees
- Kirby Puckett, Twins
- Dave Winfield, Yankees
Catchers
- Carlton Fisk, White Sox
- Terry Kennedy, Orioles
- Matt Nokes, Tigers
Pitchers
- Roger Clemens, Red Sox
- Tom Henke, Blue Jays
- Jay Howell, Athletics
- Bruce Hurst, Red Sox
- Mark Langston, Mariners
- Jack Morris, Tigers
- Dan Plesac, Brewers
- Dave Righetti, Yankees
- Bret Saberhagen, Royals
- Dave Stewart, Athletics (added to the team in 2012)
- Mike Witt, Angels
Manager:
